Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC (ASIC) Market Cap

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC has a market capitalization of $995.9M.

Financials based on reported quarter end 2025-12-31

Price: $20.72

β–Ό -0.49 (-2.31%)

Market Cap: 995.94M

NYSE Β· time unavailable

CEO: Justin G. Cohen

Sector: Financial Services

Industry: Insurance - Property & Casualty

IPO Date: 2025-06-11

Website: https://ategrity.com

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC (ASIC) - Company Information

Market Cap: 995.94M Β· Sector: Financial Services

Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC, through its subsidiaries, provides insurance and reinsurance products to small to medium-sized businesses in the United States. It offers property and casualty insurance. The company was incorporated in 2017 and is based in New York, New York. Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC is a subsidiary of Zimmer Financial Services Group LLC.

Analyst Sentiment

75%
Strong Buy

Based on 4 ratings

Analyst 1Y Forecast: $24.75

Average target (based on 2 sources)

Consensus Price Target

Low

$25

Median

$26

High

$26

Average

$26

Potential Upside: 23.1%

Price & Moving Averages

Loading chart...

Fundamentals Overview

Loading fundamentals overview...

πŸ“Š AI Financial Analysis

Powered by StockMarketInfo
Earnings Data: Q Ending 2025-12-31

"ASIC reported revenue of $123.34M for the year ending December 31, 2025, with a net income of $25.26M and earnings per share (EPS) of $0.53. The company generated operating cash flow of $41.07M and maintained a total asset base of $1.26B, against liabilities of $644.36M, resulting in total equity of $614.86M. ASIC's financial position is relatively strong with net debt of -$28.37M, indicating a healthy cash position. However, the stock is facing challenges, reflected in a significant 1-year price change of -23.78%. This negative performance, combined with the absence of dividends, affects shareholder returns despite the company's profitability metrics. The current price of $18.81 is below consensus price targets ranging between $25.5 and $26. The lack of capital expenditure and significant year-to-date decline raises concerns on growth prospects moving forward. Overall, while ASIC demonstrates solid profitability and cash flow, it faces challenges in share price performance and market sentiment."

Revenue Growth

Neutral

Revenue of $123.34M shows decent growth, but high competition may hinder future expansion.

Profitability

Positive

Net income of $25.26M provides solid margins, with a reasonable EPS of $0.53.

Cash Flow Quality

Positive

Operating cash flow of $41.07M is strong, contributing to positive free cash flow.

Leverage & Balance Sheet

Good

Strong balance sheet with total equity of $614.86M and negative net debt indicates financial stability.

Shareholder Returns

Neutral

1-year price decline of 23.78% and no dividends result in poor shareholder returns.

Analyst Sentiment & Valuation

Fair

Current price below consensus targets reflects lukewarm market sentiment.

Disclaimer:This analysis is AI-generated for informational purposes only. Accuracy is not guaranteed and this does not constitute financial advice.

Management is projecting continued outperformance and margin durability: Q1 ’26 growth is guided at +20pp vs E&S market with a combined ratio just below 90%, while Q4 delivered a record 84.9% combined ratio (loss ratio 57.1%, expense ratio 27.8%) and adjusted EPS $0.51. The Q&A adds candor on where earnings resilience could be pressured: potential rate slowdown is addressed via renewal-protection flexibility, and property severity/tariff impacts were explicitly β€œpriced in,” with property described as rate-adequate. On AI, management emphasized that it is not broadly deployed in claims yetβ€”use is currently in back-office prequalification/intake and underwriting workflow embedding is staged for 2026 after testing/ramping, implying benefits to expense ratio are not immediate. Analyst pressure focused on competition and how much guidance implies about the E&S rate environment; management refused to forecast the market and instead anchored expectations to a 60–70% casualty mix target (67% achieved). Overall tone is confident, but Q&A shows execution risk is mainly around underwriting/renewal rate stability and staged AI deployment rather than catastrophic losses or reserving.

AI IconGrowth Catalysts

  • Property premium growth +18% YoY; outperformed contracting overall property market by focusing on small-/medium-sized attritional risks
  • Casualty premiums +38% YoY with low-teens full year rate increases; management/professional liability premiums more than tripled
  • Distribution momentum: nearly 90% YoY submission volume growth; ~600 partners
  • Operating leverage from underwriting workflow automation: policy count 3.5x with record quote volumes; underwriting efficiency more than doubled; operating expense ratio -2.4 points YoY
  • AI road map operationalized: already deployed in back office (risk qualification, data prep, parameter optimization); 2026 to embed AI into underwriting workflows (in-house innovation lab) with testing/ramp through 2026

Business Development

  • Distribution network expansion via 2025 cohort: added 25% more new partners; strong early engagement
  • Project Heartland: appointment component nearing end; next phase is a branded Midwest product to convert/recognize offerings (marketing tactic + coverage/offer instantly recognized)
  • Launched Heartland brokerage package in Florida with a dedicated underwriting team
  • New England initiative: playbook for older buildings and dense mixed-use exposures
  • Midwest: doubling down on Project Heartland comprehensive branded product

AI IconFinancial Highlights

  • Gross written premiums +30% YoY (exceeded guidance by outperforming E&S industry growth by 20 percentage points)
  • Adjusted net income $25.4M vs $22.7M prior year; $0.51 adjusted EPS (diluted)
  • Net written premiums +44% YoY; net earned premiums +34% YoY (lag + quota share reduction in 2025)
  • Combined ratio 84.9% (record) vs 92.3% prior year: loss ratio 57.1% (-1.2 points YoY), expense ratio 27.8% (improved 6.1 points YoY)
  • No prior year development
  • Catastrophe losses 3.2% of net earned premium vs 3.7% prior year (few cat events in Q4)
  • Operating expense ratio 27.8%: operating expense 10.5% of net earned premiums (-2.4 points YoY); policy acquisition costs 17.3% vs 21% prior year
  • Net investment income $11.6M vs $6.3M prior year; realized+unrealized gains $6.7M (utility/infrastructure portfolio)
  • Effective tax rate 20.2%

AI IconCapital Funding

  • Share repurchase authorization size: $50 million (8-K filed; rationale tied to ~21% book value per share growth since IPO and ~9x consensus forward valuation)
  • Cash and investments +$45M QoQ to $1.1B (strong operating cash flow); book value +$26M QoQ

AI IconStrategy & Ops

  • Workflow/automation scaled to absorb growth: policy count 3.5x; record high quotes; reduced turnaround times; underwriting efficiency >2x
  • AI scope clarification: already in back office (intake/data prep/prequalification); 2026 focus is embedding AI into underwriting workflows with responsible testing/ramping during the year to drive expense ratio lower once fully deployed
  • Claims AI: not yet deployed in a meaningful way; management defines β€œback office” as before account reaches underwriter’s desk (intake β†’ data prep β†’ prequalification).

AI IconMarket Outlook

  • Q1 '26 guidance: growth rate 20 percentage points above E&S market growth (consistent with last quarter’s guidance)
  • Q1 '26 outlook: combined ratio just below 90%
  • Commentary on benchmark: if E&S is high single digits, analyst inference implies high-20s growth rate; management indicated mid- to high single digits is an appropriate benchmark for E&S market growth

AI IconRisks & Headwinds

  • Tariffs/severity risk: management explicitly priced in tariffs and other factors affecting property severity; stated property is rate-adequate despite tariffs
  • Potential rate slowdown/renewal protection flexibility: if any slowdown occurs, it may come from flexibility to protect renewals if market shifts
  • Competitive intensity: increased marginally again, but management reported no evidence of large new competitors targeting their small commercial E&S markets
  • No prior year development; reserving described as β€œhighly confident” with reserves booked anticipating late reporting

Sentiment: POSITIVE

Note: This summary was synthesized by AI from the ASIC Q4 2025 earnings transcript. Financial data is complex; please verify all metrics against official SEC filings before making investment decisions.

Loading financial data and tables...
πŸ“

SEC Filings (ASIC)

Β© 2026 Stock Market Info β€” Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC (ASIC) Financial Profile